Friday, February 24, 2006

Faster Guys, Faster..



Quaint, but its time to speed up !

The distance from Bombay to Delhi is approximately 1,300 km. From Bombay to Bangalore is 1,000 km. From Bombay to Madras is, maybe, 1,100 km. Now, if I wanted to go to Delhi by train, I could board the Rajdhani at 4 pm in the evening in Bombay and reach next morning around 9.00 am. Total time taken is 17 hours. More than the 17 hours taken, I can work most of the day in Bombay and catch a train. The same applies when if I want to travel to Bombay from Delhi.

Now, if I wish to travel from Bombay to Bangalore, its a different story. One train I know leaves in the morning and reaches next morning. Another leaves in the evening and arrives next evening. It takes 24 hours, not a minute more, not a minute less. Its the same story with Madras. And it has taken the same time for perhaps 30 years. Its possible that before that it took less time. As has been demonstrated in some sectors.

Railway Minister Lalu Prasad Yadav has unveiled a new railway budget full of small steps which are good. They suggest a determination to change things. They also reflect an attempt to cater to aspirations. Like the introduction of more affordable air-conditioned trains. But not one real step that either acknowledges or attempts to acknowledge the fact that for the best part since Independence, speed has never been the essence in the railway economy.

Digital Economy & Real Economy

The contrast between the digital economy which allows Bangalore to connect with the rest of the world instantaneously and the real economy where trains to Bangalore take longer than to the capital couldn't be more stark. In effect, the government's priority in connecting the political capital to its state capitals continues to remain higher than connecting its economic growth centres to the rest of the country.


Yes, there is a Rs 22,000 crore dedicated freight corridor in the west and east. The project is to be inaugurated by the Prime Minister. The intention is laudable. But, the track record of similar large size projects is woeful. Like the limping Golden Quadrilateral. And in a knowledge/services economy, people movement should be priority. Not just between Delhi and Agra or Kanpur. Of course freight should move quickly. But you need both. People often tend to assume its one for the other.

Nor am I saying we should not have Rajdhanis running to Delhi in high speed and comfort. All I am saying is that we need to have superfast (not defined in railway terminology) trains that run to the new economic centres. And these are not new any more. This is not because Air Deccan will undercut Indian Railways. Its because a country can only progress faster if it moves faster. And I mean the larger mass, not the handful who can afford air-fares. And its the lack of efforts in this direction which is sad. And the refusal of the Railways to focus on this makes it worse.

Konkan Railway Tried

Former Konkak Railway Corporation MD B Rajaram wanted to run trains at over 150 kmph down the western corridor. He even conducted a few succesful tests. Which would have meant Bombay-Goa in less than five hours. By train ! The Indian Railways (the parent organisation) stymied it. The fact that KRC has seen more than its share of accidents hasn't helped. And like everything else, the baby got thrown out with the bath water. Instead we had talk of bullet trains between Bombay and Ahmedabad. That's like trying to fly before walking.


Even these guys can go faster, if you want to them to

So, if trains can run from Bombay to Delhi in 17 hours, Bombay-Bangalore could technically be done in, maybe, 15. Imagine, boarding at 7 pm at Dadar station and alighting at 8.30 am in central Bangalore. Sure, it will call for schedule changes, track upgradation et al. But that does not mean it cannot be done.

Wonder if this railway minister or previous ones have noted that visiting heads of state often visit Bangalore first before coming to Delhi. Or for that matter Hyderabad. Albeit that city will be second port of call in George Bush's itinerary. Does anyone think why they don't visit Patna, or, for that matter Lucknow ? The answer stares at your face. Economic centres outweigh political centres of importance. If people outside the country can recognise it, why can't we ?

8 comments:

Balaji on 11:34 pm said...

A very well illustrated point. But i have to say one thing that India is one of the few counrties very well connected with rail and trains travel to almost every place in India and is affordable for common man. I think the security aspect should be improved before we think of faster trains. Have a fast trains run in railways lines with open road crossings is welcoming disaster. I think security should be and need to be given more importance.

ankan on 9:07 am said...

Govind

You have tried good arguments indeed.

With the rise of airline sector, I think railways will cater to the less previledged class particularly in terms of long distance travel. Sure, there is a 17 hr train between Delhi and Mumbai but the major chunk of Delhi-Mumbai travel is on airlines. Same thing is going to be true for Mumbai-Bangalore.

A Madras-Bangalore superfast train, harnessing latest technology, makes much more sense than a Mumbai-Bangalore.

Neelakantan on 5:03 pm said...

Rajdhani ho hum. How about a series of tech expresses, appropriately named (in Mbps) connecting Bombay, Bangalore, Chennai, Hyderabad, Pune would be great.
All these are achievable in overnight distance. After all buses do bombay-bangalore in sub 20 hours (with all the diversions).

Gursartaj on 7:55 pm said...

When there are trains running at 300kmph in other parts of the world, why should we be left behind?
G

Anonymous said...

Hi there
I found this blog very interesting but am intriqued and offended by the assertions that trains are "for the less priveleged." I am a British journalist living in the UK and have just returned from India. I am also going there later this year and need to travel from Mumbai to Delhi. I plan to travel by train and would not describe myself as "less priveleged." I don't know if Ankan is aware that for a foreigner to fly from Mumbai to Delhi costs about £200 one way and double return - which is close to the cost of my international flight. If I had money like that to throw around I would rather spend it on a five star hotel upon arrival in Delhi than on a boring two hour flight. As it is what with the cost of my internationla flight, reasonable hotels and so on, the trip to India is already costing me enough so I plan to take the train. And it is Jet Airway's loss. Why is it the case that foreigners have to pay such an amount to fly when it only costs Indians 4,000 rupees? Yes, if the price was 4,000 rupees for me I would fly everywhere. If Indians had to pay that amount would they think of trains as being for the "less priveleged?" Well, I am planning on taking the train and am glad there is a fast one I can take to Delhi so enjoyed reading this blog. It's about time arilines stopped charging foreigners excessive amounts. In the new world order Indians earn the same as if not more than their Western counterparts so it is a ridiculous system.

Govindraj Ethiraj on 8:01 am said...

I agree with you entirely..differential rates for foreigners is one of the most ridiculous things we have to live and suffer with..precisely because it draws such (and rightly so) comments from vistors and guests like you..

We've adopted a similar approach to our monuments which again is most embrassing. Prime Minister Manmohan Singh did say he was looking into the monument part a few months ago. But such disparities ARE an issue that need to be addressed very seriously and urgently. Stay in touch.

Do write in to govindraj@datelinebombay.com
Author

Allergy treatment drugs on 6:10 pm said...

Allergy generic and brand name drugs

Allegra generic drug contains an antihistamine and decongestant used to relieve allergy symptoms such as itchy red eyes, stuffy nose and throat irritation. Order discount Allegra pharmacy online

Claritin-D generic drug is an antihistamine and decongestant combination used to treat the nasal congestion (stuffy nose), sneezing, and runny nose caused by colds and hay fever. Antihistamine and decongestant combinations are used to treat the nasal congestion (stuffy nose), sneezing, and runny nose caused by colds and hay fever.Order discount Claritin-D pharmacy online

Flonase generic drug is a nasal corticosteroid that works directly on nasal tissue to reduce swelling and inflammation. The medication is used to treat itching, runny nose, postnasal drip, nasal congestion and sneezing in people with a history of rhinitis. Order discount generic Flonase pharmacy online

Nasacort generic drug is a nasal steroid that works directly on nasal tissue to reduce swelling and inflammation. It is used to treat nasal itching, runny nose, postnasal drip, nasal congestion and sneezing associated with allergic rhinitis. Order discount generic Nasacort pharmacy online

SINGULAIR generic drug is a prescription medicine approved to help control asthma in adults and children as young as 12 months and to help relieve the symptoms of seasonal allergies in adults and children as young as 2 years.SINGULAIR will NOT replace fast-acting inhalers for sudden symptoms. You should still have rescue medication available and continue to take your other asthma medications unless your doctor tells you to stop. For asthma, SINGULAIR should be taken once a day, in the evening as prescribed, whether or not you have asthma symptoms. If your symptoms get worse or you need to increase the use of your rescue inhaler, call your doctor at once. Order discount generic Singulair pharmacy online

Zyrtec generic drug is an antihistamine which provides relief of allergy symptoms such as watery eyes, runny nose, itching eyes, sneezing, itching and hives. Order discount generic Zyrtec pharmacy online.

MOON on 12:18 pm said...

牙醫,植牙,矯正,矯正牙齒,批發,皮膚科,痘痘,中醫,飛梭雷射,毛孔粗大,醫學美容,痘痘,肉毒桿菌,seo,關鍵字行銷,自然排序,網路行銷,自然排序,關鍵字行銷seo,部落格行銷,網路行銷,seo,關鍵字行銷,自然排序,部落格行銷,網路行銷,牛舌餅婚紗台中婚紗,腳臭,腳臭,腳臭,腳臭,腳臭,腳臭,腳臭,腳臭,高雄婚紗,街舞,小產,雞精,性感,辣妹,雷射溶脂,雙下巴,抽脂,瘦小腹,微晶瓷,電波拉皮,淨膚雷射,清潔公司,居家清潔,牙周病,牙齒矯正,植牙

 

Copyright 2008 All Rights Reserved Revolution Two Church theme by Brian Gardner Converted into Blogger Template by Bloganol dot com