Skip to main content

Why ISB will surely beat The IIMs (Thanks To Mr Arjun Singh)

Last year, as a panel member for HSBC's annual scholarships, I (with my co-panelists) was struck by the brilliance of a young boy from a village near Delhi. A farmer's son, he had pulled through his academic career almost entirely through scholarships. And here he was applying for the big one, perhaps the biggest.

There was no debating his sheer grit and raw intelligence. And yet, the boy had had an advantage. He had, somewhere in his first few years of school, applied and enrolled for the Jawahar Navodaya Vidyala. These are not schools some of us living in cities are likely to see while driving into work. For the simple reason, they are not to be found here.

The residential Navodayas are another model of excellence, like the IITs and IIMs. They aim to create a class of bright, young students, mostly from rural and small town India. They give the opportunities that the current schooling system does not. And allows some of them to compete on equal footing from the (snobs !) from St Stephens in Delhi and St Xaviers in Bombay. Notably for scholarships like this one.

Rajiv Gandhi's Idea

The Navodayas were a brainchild of Rajiv Gandhi. I will admit I didn't know about their existence till that day. And two members of the panel, Business Standard editor T N Ninan and author/writer Ramachandra Guha subsequently entered into a lively but furious debate about Rajiv Gandhi's contribution to India. Two sparkling lines I recall from that exchange were, "The problem with you economists is that you forget history." And the retort, "And the problem with the historians is that they don't understand economics."

Lets accept that this model of excellence works, whether for Navodayas or IITs/IIMs. And the fact is that it has stood the test of time and delivered. Actually, much more than it was perhaps ever envisaged. But that's the true test of any great model, in business or otherwise. Im pretty sure the Navodayas will deliver too, to greater heights. They already are. But possibly they escape the attention of people like me.

And yet, we are intent on destroying this model. By adding even more reservation to our premier institutions of excellence. Its plain shocking to see the government pushing through reservation in the IITs and IIMs. The recent constitutional amendment allows the government to add another 27.5% for OBCs for a host of other institutions as well. These include AIIMs to FTII and NIFT, as I learn from the Indian Express this morning.
That takes total reservation to 49.5%. Wow !

More Seats Not A Solution

HRD minister Arjun Singh's (the architect of this plan) response to the protests is that the institutes should increase the number of seats to allow for the reservations. Theoritically okay but practically disasterous. An increase in seats should be driven by the economic models of demand and supply. And capabilities. Not by fiat. As is the case here.

But a HRD minister running educational institutions cannot think like a Railway Minister. Announce more trains whenever a constituency grumbles. When he should be thinking of a brand new railway system. What's worse is that in doing all this, the Congress government seems to strike at the very Nehruvian model of excellence that has brought so much of equity to India. And to themselves. At least in the past.

I compared (in my previous post) the Indian School of Business with the Indian Institute of Managements. That comparison reflected some familiarity and bias in favour of the number two. As opposed to the entrenched number one. It also assumed that the IIMs are more or less on an equal footing when it comes to developing world class teaching systems, getting the best professors and creating the best learning environments. And finally, taking in the students they WANT to take in.

How An Institution Goes To Seed

Arjun Singh wants to change the rules of the game. Halfway. I cannot now make a fair comparison between an IIM and an ISB or a AIIMS and lets say, the Manipal Institutes. Because the model of excellence that these fine institutions represented is being taken apart. In addition to diluting their present and past equity. I should know. I belong to a south Bombay college which once boasted the best and finest this country has produced.

I would once count the number of alumni from my college whose statues adorn various streets and corners of south Bombay. Incidentally, that includes a gentleman by the name of BR Ambedkar ! Whose statues of course are to be found all over the country. Anyway, all this is truly history now. And one key reason I would think is that Elphinstone College one day was taken over by the state government. Nothing wrong in that per se. Except that there was no model of excellence applied. And all attempts at meritocracy went downhill.

Which is why I think Arjun Singh's move must be opposed strongly. With all the vehemance at the command of every existing and past student of these institutions. The quiet manner in which its been pushed through is menacing, to say the least. And the fact that all political parties support it, is sad.

Protest And Offer Solutions

There is a larger problem here. Of our inability to understand what is going or has gone wrong with our education system. Of how there is a very large India out there that is reaching out to the politicians to do something for them. Possibly because they are alienated from the great IT/BPO story that we write about everyday. Or the live images of Lakme Fashion Week on all-time television.

But that's no excuse for the politicians to respond with such terribly unimaginative moves. The politicians seem to have guaged an undercurrent of discontent in the polity. As they often do. Their solutions to address this discontent are retrogade. While we oppose the moves, we must offer solutions as well. Even as we acknowledge that India is not about what you and I see everyday, with the booming stock markets and glitzy malls. That's how Nehru would have thought.

Comments

Ravi Kamdar said…
Till this week, I was wondering, How IIMs and IITs reach to this stage? Answer is only LUCK. It was their luck that politicians did not intervene much. So they nurtured. But now, politicians are here.

Hey, if IIM has good lecturers which made this students so great, they will have to take care of this matter now.Lets see how good their management is.

I think IIM and IIT alumni should do something..
Selma Mirza said…
I feel very strongly about this too. Reservations are just not the answer.
Unknown Indian said…
Agreed. The only hope for IIMs is if Tendu Raja also forces reservations in ISB!
GBO said…
Hi Govind, this, too, shall pass.

On another subject, boss, as a biz journo who I respect (whatever that is). . . (and I have more than once been in the crowds in front of you as well as maybe on a panel or three with you in the past) . . . I would have thought that the subject of selling over MRP would be something you would have known more about.


And cared, too.

Cheers/DD's rum drinking and driving pal.
GE said…
GBO

Now I am wondering ! My obsevations on MRP were purely in the context of whether a Pilot in Command should be overly concerned..not on the merit of MRP itself.

Though, I must admit I am struck by the ferocity of your case in the Air Deccan episode. To that extent, I must perhaps think again.

Either way, this has no bearing on the MRP debate vis-a-vis my local pan ka dukaan etc. With you on that. Does the Weights & Measures Act differentiate ? You've studied it extensively..!

And meanwhile, if you can recall/relate specific instances on pilot culpability in the `frisking' matter that you raised, maybe you want to share them, privately if not publicly..!
Anonymous said…
I think whole faculty of IITs and IIMs shud take a firm stand against it and if possible resign from their position to voice their opinions to the deaf ears of arjun singh and co.IT's been since long that govt has been bossing arnd on IITs and IIMs just because they fund them...it has really reached to a sickening extent of interference...
!xobile said…
Reservations Suck!
Join In
http://50is2much.blogspot.com
This 'higher education'thing has now become a sickening stuff. I guess this was the same Arjun singh, who provided succor to the IIMs two years back by doing away with the "high-fees" hullabaloo of his predecessor Mr MM Joshi, and now this! I guess if IIMs (and other such institutes of higher learning, barring few) could have only lowered the entrance fees to say Rs 100, a more diverse people and from economically challenged section might have been able to attempt such exams frequently. This wouldn’t have given any excuse to impose such quotas on them. I would much rather have Arjun singh restrict this entrance fee racket that prevents so many interested candidates from getting into these inst. And as with any other other problem, the leaders have again chosen a wrong means to solve the problem, while the real issue will always linger long after the bills have been passed, implemented (ask several quota candidates at IITs and they will narrate tales of depression and complexes!) and everyone, including Mr Dholakia would go back to their nice easy sarkari jobs. Don’t think any of the professors have the guts to challenge this!
GBO said…
how do i send you an email please??
Anonymous said…
GBO !

At govindraj@datelinebombay.com

Cheers

GE
Bombay Addict said…
GE - Touche. Reservations are indeed not the answer. Yet, good to see the way the India Bloggers are unifying on this.

Yesterday's Big Fight (NDTV), where OBC students staged a walkout on a debate on this issue, made a very interesting watch.

No dissenting posts in the Indian blogosphere as yet ?
Anonymous said…
UPA govt. is planning to pass a bill introducing 50% quota for reservation in all Central Universities,including IITs\IIMs. Next there will be reservation in Private companies also. UPA govt. has already proposed that. So it is imperative that we protest strongly against the reservation in Central Universities (including IITs\IIMs) and see to it that this bill is not passed. If we succeed we would have done a great thing to ourselves, our kids and our nation.
PLEASE SIGN THE PETITION AGAINST QUOTAS
AT
http://www.petitiononline.com/No_Quota/. It takes just one minute. Please do this to save ourselves,our institutions, our future generation and our Nation. Remember each and every signature counts.
desh said…
These politician dont give a damn. Infact these people dont need to send their children to any of the institutes. Their sons and daughters go to Havard for an MBA come back, beat an established player in politics in Elections and are chosen to parliament(you are somewhere in Mumbai so u must know better).
And some coming from a rich political family lineage dont come up with a Graduate for three generations and still come up with 3 Prime Ministers the fourth one not admitting to be one, fifth one waiting in the pipeline along with his colombian girlfriend on the sidelines(I forgot to mention a family planning machine, poor fellow died in a air crash....voila something good...his son a graduate)...
They dont need to anything...Its us the seedha sadha nothing doing Middle Class Junta who take the beating and dont we love to take it...
To its fine continue...
Manas said…
http://o3.indiatimes.com/quotablog

Our politicians can politicize anything at all in the world (even the kitchen sink) Just yesterday I heard some idiot from the congress saying that the uuper caste has had its share of reservations for 3000 years and now it is the turn of lower castes . Good heavens man!! how do you propose to reason with such fanatics. ...... First of all most backward class resides in villages and 99.99% of them dont give a damn about higher education they need agriculture to sustain themselves and instead of of uplifting them in their particular field by investing more in places where they earn their livelyhood the government proposes to uproot them and throw them somewhere they have no future and they decide to take away the white collar jobs away from white collar people . I mean no disrespect my point is that a person can (in general and not for exceptions ) work in an environment that they have grow in. We will always need workers and labourers and there will be sweepers and garabage collector instead of glorifying technical education we can improve working conditions in such menial jobs to uplift the backward class because evry person who does a job that is hygienically unacceptable to the rest of the community he or she will be looked down upon. Even in very developed countries garabage collector are not respected by the community but they certainly do have better livin conditions than in our qwn country.
Anonymous said…
I understand the complete lack of rationale behind reservations...at least in areas such as higher professional education. Unfortunately, if you badger about with comments such as "snobs" from St. Stephen's College, Delhi etc, you will probably infuriate a section of society that has actually been trying to make a difference. Maybe you should look back through history and try and see WHY St. Stephen's or St. Xavier's have excelled, and why even today Stephanians and Xavieriites the world over command the kind of respect NO OTHER institute in India has been able to do. Anyway, think about it!!!
indiyouth said…
y ppl like you havent ever protested or criticised against management quota....
and y u blabber all the time about IITs and IIMs

Mst ppl blabbering here dont even figure in the top 10,000 ranks qaurter of which is required to get a iit seat

and most ppl dont mention colleges like st stephens of delhi which are minority institutions where there is quota for christians and still nobody blabbers about its quality although it has 25% christian quota..Despite that it is the best college of DU and only above 95%ers take admission there..

you ppl are hypocrites
www.reservationfacts.blogspot.com
indiyouth said…
http://reservationfacts.blogspot.com

Popular posts from this blog

Why Did Aamir Khan Swing For Narmada ?

He is not the first celebrity to do so. But he’s turned out to be the most radical, activist Bollywood filmstar by far, all in day's time..at least as far as my memory serves me.

The reasons why he would back the Narmada Bachao Aandolan
could be several. Ranging from the fact that a cousin associated with the movement influenced him to the fact that he was in and out of the Kutch for six months whilst the shooting of Lagaan.

Lets assume all that contributed significantly. Still, why join the protestors in the manner he did ? Why become a face for the movement ? Knowing well there could be consequences that may not be the most desirable.

Dammed If You Do..

To his credit, he did not buckle to the mob frenzy that followed his signing up a few days ago. Instead, he calmly called the attention of all and sundry and asked if these were really the politicians and political parties they wanted to be led by ? He even accused the political parties of trying to bully him.

There are those who de…

Jan Lokpal Bill Movement: Lessons For India's Middle & Ruling Classes

`Supercop' Kiran Bedi learnt the hard way (or so we hope) how not to hold fort when she resorted to somewhat unusual theatrics to drive home a point about elected representatives. She was on stage as Gandhian Anna Hazare fasted to get the Indian Government to agree to pass the Jan LokPal Bill, a strong anti-corruption bill. His fast ended on 28 August 2011, 12 days after it started.

The fast (and the strategy thereof) has attracted kudos and criticism alike. The critics call the fast and the accompanying protests blackmail. The supporters say politicians are not known to respond to the usual greet, meet and review process. As they have not in the past. Moreover, the country has lived with unprecedented levels of corruption for decades and across all walks of life. And cannot tolerate it any longer. Extreme conditions call for extreme responses. Both sides however agree that the issue of corruption in public life must be addressed, with some urgency.

I see it a little differently.…

The Zone

I was watching Indian captain MS Dhoni's eyes when he hit the sixer that catapulted India to victory at the ICC Cricket World Cup 2011 on Saturday night. Only someone with numbing focus and meditative concentration, oblivious to the utter mayhem and cacophony all around, can play a shot like that. It was the definitive, you-guys-can-take-this stroke from a cricketer wanting to leave a permanent stamp on the game.

To be fair, many such definitive shots have been played, match winning and otherwise. But it was one of the few I would categorize as belonging to The Zone. Spiritual expert Jaya Row who once defined the Zone to me. "Its your ability to disconnect totally from the world outside and be in total control of your mind and body for that moment," she had told me.

I have always wondered about the role of spirituality (secular) in our lives. Ms Row, a Vedanta expert, defined ita appropriately. "Think of Sachin Tendulkar when he is facing a bowler. Look at his face…