Skip to main content

India's Feudal Politicians - II

In July 2000, a boy was discovered by Scotland Yard in a `drunk and incapableÂ’ state at Leicester Square, the heart of London's West End. If you've been to Leicester Square as I have, particularly on Friday night, the most likely state you will find anyone is drunk and incapable ! That's one good way to put your worries behind and have a jolly good time, I would think.

Anyway, this boy seemed in bad shape, "lying on the ground, clearly ill," and he had been vomiting. An ambulance was called and medics determined that he did not need hospitalization. He was then hauled off to Charing Cross police station, not too far off. When questioned, Euan John, as he called himself, gave an old address and a date of birth which made him appear over 18 years of age.

Here is another London story. William Straw, all of 17, was caught by the police after he tried to sell $17 worth of cannabis to a lady reporter who was apparently following up on a tip she had received concerning the young man's activities. At some point, the story made it to the news, though not in the manner it was planned.


No prizes for guessing, both these adventurous boys are sons of powerful British politicians. Before we come to what happened to them, lets see what would have happened in India, were similar incidents to occur. Take the first case. Well, you would not even know about it because chances are that the affair would have been suppressed right there.

The second would have been tougher, but rest assured the reporter would have been in jail. Actually that happened in Britain as well, for possession of cannabis. But more on that later. Not quite here. Not only would the reporter be in jail, a private secretary to the politician concerned would have issued a statement saying, "Politicians or their wards cannot be exposed to sting operations."

Fix The Witnesses

Next day, there would have been a hue and cry in parliament asking for the heads of the reporter concerned and maybe the publisher or owner of the media house as well. Surprised ? Well, let me assure you this has already happened not once but many times over in recent years. And the beauty is that this behavior inevitably cuts across party lines.

What would have happened to the legal case, if any ? Well nothing. Witnesses would have either been bought out, threatened or hounded out. The chief inspector of the police station in question would have been transferred, ideally by next morning. The constable who effected the arrest would have been hiding in his house, or looking for another job. All the while fearing for his and his familiy's safety.

So, by the time the matter reached the courts, if it did, all would have been resolved, under the table or over. Else, it would have been put behind as a little prank the boys played. Maharashtra state revenue minister Narayan Rane usually does that when his sons go out of control in their locality in Mumbai (Bombay), which until recently was the same as mine. Click on this link if you donÂ’t believe me. But then, I don't know who one should fear more, the father or the sons, or the trio.

Back In London

Lets return to the cooler climes of London. The first case involved Euan Blair, son of British Prime Minister Tony Blair. As per law, the boy's parents were summoned to the police station. They didn't go to Charing Cross, but Kennington, to avoid the media onslaught. So that was one concession. According to reports, the parents and son were there for 30 minutes while, among other things, Euan was reprimanded severely by the inspector in charge.

Downing Street later stressed that “Mr Blair and his wife Cherie acted as `appropriate adults' at the police station when police would have spelled out `in ordinary language' to Euan the full consequences of his punishment. So, the prime minister and his wife had no choice but to behave like normal parents and pay the price for their son's excesses. Obviously, the media had a field day all through.

In the second case, Jack Straw was forced to do something similar. Actually, I read the account as published by then Daily Mirror editor Piers Morgan in his book The Insider (an amazing read actually). In the book, Morgan describes how the Mirror was first tipped off that William Straw was into the drugs scene at a pub near the family's London home in Clapham.

A Drug Deal That Blew Up

Morgan says he sent two of his top investigative reporters, Dawn Alford and Tanith Carey to take a look, undercover. After getting a little friendly at the pub, Alford ended up buying the cannabis from William. Now comes the fascinating bit and do bear with me as I narrate from the book, a copy of which I have. Even as Morgan and his team debated what to do with the information they brought back, Alford got a call from William Straw's pub mate to say there was another big party the coming Saturday night and there would be `plenty of drugs'.

At this point Morgan says his team debated the matter. The decision, arrived in consultation with legal help, was not to run an expose because the boy was a minor. However, since the law was likely to be broken again and since the father of the son was the home secretary, they would call the father and alert him. Morgan called up Straw and in a conversation mentioned that the latter's son had been caught selling drugs.

Morgan says Straw called him back the next day and said his son had confirmed that he had indeed sold drugs. "We are still talking over it as a family and I will let you know if we will be saying something," said Straw to Daily Mirror's Morgan. At this point Morgan's interest was the putting the story out and ensuring no one else did it first. He hung up after eliciting a promise from Straw that the Mirror would like to know first.

Boils Down To Functioning Democracy

The next day Morgan ran into a government functionary who revealed that Straw had visited the local police station the previous day and reported the event. Straw apparently concluded that a crime had been committed and as Home Secretary, he had no choice but to report it. Dawn Alford, the reporter who bought the cannabis from William, went to the police station to give a statement and was arrested. Later, she was released on bail.

The press went to town with it, without naming Jack Straw because the law prevented the naming of the minor. In the headlines, he was "a Cabinet Minister" whose son had been trapped in a drug deal. The media, not surprisingly, was on the issue for several weeks. As it happened, despite an injunction and gag orders, all the names eventually made it into public domain.

Several things emerge from this. For one, democracy works better in Britain than it does in India. Of this, I am pretty clear about. Particularly since I have interacted with British politicians and seen the system at work. Which is not to say the British system does not have its problems or scandals. Of course it does. And there are no dearth of scoundrels either.

Moral Of The Story ?

The point is that for whatever reason, strategic, political, opportunistic or plain common sensical, both politicians did the right thing. Which is to co-operate with the law and not subvert it. British media did allege that there was favourable treatment in both cases. And there may have been. Intrerestingly, both politicians were on the backfoot trying to defend their respective positions. And not on the attack saying, "If I don't get privileged treatment, who will ?"

The moral of this long story is that our political class operates differently. They are two sets of rules, for the rulers and the ruled. I am not saying this applies to all politicians but surely a few who can make life difficult for you and me. I shudder to think what would happen if my car were to accidentally cross a Narayan Rane family member. I would expect that my being a `media person' may help, but god knows how and when.

What would have happened if the BJP were in power, Pramod Mahajan alive and his son Rahul Mahajan found drunk and drugged with his secretary lying comatose next to him. Well, you know what happened without the BJP being in power and the father no more. Forget the legal complicity, remember the bit about the `poor' 31-year-old boy making a mistake.

And then, what's changed is really the media, particularly the 24/7 variety. Think about it. That's the only thing that might make the likes of Deshmukh, Rane and the countless other feudal politicians ruling this country think twice before they let their wrath loose on their subjects.

Thank you to all of you for sharing your thoughts on a subject I feel strongly about as well - this is a sequel to the previous post on our arrogant and feudal politicians. Instead of responding individually as I would have liked to, I thought I would put down the next instalment in this train of thought..

Comments

Anonymous said…
Govind,

nice piece why didnt you draw in the parallel of Bina Ramanis jailing ? That SIT was set up to investigate a murder and instead is going hammer and tongs at one of the only 3 people who atleast didnt turn hostile, never mind the quality of their deposition. Ila
Anonymous said…
To the anonymous person above,
Bina Ramani(although not a politician) is also one of the priviledged classes who is trying to escape punishment. Her crimes:
1)Operating a bar without license
2)Trying to destroy evidence
Instead of owning up to the crimes, she says that her prosecution is politically motivated with the aim of silencing her. She is part of the problem, not a victim. Of course,Manu Sharma et. al. are a bigger problem.
George
Anonymous said…
Dear Ila/George

Agree with both of you..allow me to enclose this extract of an interesting piece that appeared in the latest Outlook, by Rajinder Puri..link after that.

"Years ago, after one of the numerous political demonstrations I participated in, I spent four nights in Tihar jail, class C, with 18 workers as a common criminal falsely charged with criminal trespass. The authorities wanted to teach me a lesson. The experience differed from earlier arrests as a political detainee. For three years, each month, all the accused 19 appeared in Tis Hazari courts in that spurious case. With no evidence, the case dragged on. It was plain harassment. One day I complained to the late Jag Parvesh. I criticised his rotten government. He must have intervened. The case was promptly withdrawn. See? That’s how the system works!"

http://www.outlookindia.com/full.asp?fodname=20061002&fname=Bulls+Eye&sid=1

GE
PS said…
Govind,

I sometimes wonder why smart, hardworking, qualified professionals continue to bring up families in India. Do patriotic feelings need to well up in the citizens of a country who are denied justice almost everyday? Does the fate of being born within a man-made boundary create in us a loyality towards it? Is the nation state such a scared entity that we need to be loyal at any cost? Or is it our culture that we feel for? A culture which gives solace for the morons who rule us? Maybe I'm mixing up too many issues here, but I fail to understand why more smart people in India don't consider moving to the UK or the US if they felt justice was better served there? Maybe it's already happening, but maybe the matrix that is India provides enough fuel for us to keeping talking about what can be done better, what can improve, of what punishment or reform we would like to offer the crooks who run this country. There's so much to fight about, so much to argue about, so many reasons to call for bandhs and fast-unto-deaths, so many reasons for hostility in the name of religion, caste and language. I can imagine many hardened Indians rubbing their hands at this delightful, yet jingoistic prospect.
Shweta said…
Hi Govind,
This post truly echos my sentiments on the issue. Ofcourse, this prefrential treatment is not restricted to politicians alone, but people who have the money to buy out the system. Sometime back, the CEO of Coors Beer got arrested in Denver for driving under the infulence of alcohol. He was not drunk, but the alcohol level in his blood was over the permissable limit. His licence has been revoked! Very recently Paris Hilton was arrested for DUI..each time I read something like this..I cant help wonder if an Unbaised Law and Order system will ever prevail in India.
Anunag said…
hi,

Excellent post. The british have more respect to the written law than we do.
What with the level of criminalization in Indian politics, it'll be long before democracy succeeds..
Anonymous said…
Govind

Great posts. It really galls me that a lowlife like Rane became CM of Maharashtra ... and that he is now the epitome of secular politics as a part of the Congress.

What irritates me even more is when feudal politicians like Horrati, the Karnataka education minister threaten to throw 250,000 kids out of school in Karnataka for daring to learn in a language of their choice, and noone seems concerned about it.
Hiren said…
Very revealing post and very very interesting. Democracy is only for literate socieities. Only more and more transparency can bring political accountability. Just iaagine the situation when only Doordarshan was there- at least satellite TV has made the media somewhat strong.
Gaurav Shukla said…
Sir,

with due respect to you, why didn't you run for MP-election or campaign for a most appropriate candidate.

I tell you one thing..the major reason why we are still in such a bad shape of democracy is because our ppl are not that much active/aware..politicians all over the World are corrupt/power-hungry/pushy..but to what degree depends upon voters and there degree of activeness/awareness in insuring proper democracy.

In developed World, a highschool passout kid's dream(actually amongst top5 dreams) would be to become PM/President of his/her country..and there are proper/ethical channels to become one..but here in India ..you have to be either a actor/actress/criminal-turned acter(all of us know Sanjay Datt was about to become MP after his father's death if it wouldn't have been no-criminal-can-run-for-elections Act!!)Criminal/Civil-Servant/Wards of Politicians ONLY!! there is no way for a normal man(say a Captain from army)...last heard Abu Salem is about to run for UP-MLA-elections from Azamgarh[Bablu Shrivastava also had plans for same but thanks to verdict from Bombay HC..his dreams shattered]..and voters in his constituency still percieve him as a boy who ran to bombay to become an actor(he is still an innocent man..innocent untill proven guilty!!)

What are YOU and your cribbing-about-india-is-my favourite-Timepass colleges are doing to make ppl in Azamgarh aware about abu salem??

after all..

"In a democracy, ppl get what they deserve" - ..
Gaurav Shukla said…
my previous comment has some typo's -

campaigned
the
their
ensuring
colleagues
Anonymous said…
Today Bombay blast case of 1993 is being decided and the culprits as identified by the agency being punished acoordingly by court.
Who initiated the entire problem i.e. BABRI MASZID demolition by handful of very senior politicians for their gain.
What happened to their case lying pending in different courts ? Why they are not hanged or sentenced to life improsinment ?
Every Indian or all citizens of the entire world should debate on Indian politicians and punish them for ever.
Take this message and explain to each Indian that first these politicians should be punished, hanged then only ordinary citizens.
Alok said…
Very good. A good analysis.

Alok

Popular posts from this blog

Why Did Aamir Khan Swing For Narmada ?

He is not the first celebrity to do so. But he’s turned out to be the most radical, activist Bollywood filmstar by far, all in day's time..at least as far as my memory serves me.

The reasons why he would back the Narmada Bachao Aandolan
could be several. Ranging from the fact that a cousin associated with the movement influenced him to the fact that he was in and out of the Kutch for six months whilst the shooting of Lagaan.

Lets assume all that contributed significantly. Still, why join the protestors in the manner he did ? Why become a face for the movement ? Knowing well there could be consequences that may not be the most desirable.

Dammed If You Do..

To his credit, he did not buckle to the mob frenzy that followed his signing up a few days ago. Instead, he calmly called the attention of all and sundry and asked if these were really the politicians and political parties they wanted to be led by ? He even accused the political parties of trying to bully him.

There are those who de…

Jan Lokpal Bill Movement: Lessons For India's Middle & Ruling Classes

`Supercop' Kiran Bedi learnt the hard way (or so we hope) how not to hold fort when she resorted to somewhat unusual theatrics to drive home a point about elected representatives. She was on stage as Gandhian Anna Hazare fasted to get the Indian Government to agree to pass the Jan LokPal Bill, a strong anti-corruption bill. His fast ended on 28 August 2011, 12 days after it started.

The fast (and the strategy thereof) has attracted kudos and criticism alike. The critics call the fast and the accompanying protests blackmail. The supporters say politicians are not known to respond to the usual greet, meet and review process. As they have not in the past. Moreover, the country has lived with unprecedented levels of corruption for decades and across all walks of life. And cannot tolerate it any longer. Extreme conditions call for extreme responses. Both sides however agree that the issue of corruption in public life must be addressed, with some urgency.

I see it a little differently.…

The Zone

I was watching Indian captain MS Dhoni's eyes when he hit the sixer that catapulted India to victory at the ICC Cricket World Cup 2011 on Saturday night. Only someone with numbing focus and meditative concentration, oblivious to the utter mayhem and cacophony all around, can play a shot like that. It was the definitive, you-guys-can-take-this stroke from a cricketer wanting to leave a permanent stamp on the game.

To be fair, many such definitive shots have been played, match winning and otherwise. But it was one of the few I would categorize as belonging to The Zone. Spiritual expert Jaya Row who once defined the Zone to me. "Its your ability to disconnect totally from the world outside and be in total control of your mind and body for that moment," she had told me.

I have always wondered about the role of spirituality (secular) in our lives. Ms Row, a Vedanta expert, defined ita appropriately. "Think of Sachin Tendulkar when he is facing a bowler. Look at his face…